I’ve been experimenting with the Windows Sidebar preview. The same sidebar that was shown in the Windows Vista Pre-Beta 1 release. As it turns out a couple of people had that pre-beta build and were able to modify the files to make them run on a Windows XP machine. So, after I got the Sidebar working, I zipped up the files, changes the instructions, and am making it available here. We’ll see how long that lasts.
After running the sidebar for about a week, it reminds me of a reincarnated idea of the Windows 95 Active Desktop. Remember that? You where supposed to be able to add any type HTML content (Active Content) as your desktop background. Interesting idea, but became more annoying than useful after a while. Especially since it seemed to break weekly.
While I love the clock gadget, the search gadget is annoying (at least in this preview version). When you search for someting, it pops open an IE window with your results in search.msn.com… boring. They need to tie something in the MSN Desktop search windows to make this better. The RSS feed box is very limited. The preview version only allows you to add a single RSS source. The photo viewer is nice, but doesn’t really have a practical business application.
Another annoyance is the amount of real estate it takes up on the desktop. When you maximize a window, it expands just up to the edge of the side bar. You can drag windows around the desktop and under the sidebar to move them out of the way, but the side bar always stays on top. That means you can’t click the close, min, max buttons on any windows under the sidebar. It really needs to have a send to background option, and a hide, or shrink to the side feature. You sould also be able to reduce and expand the amount of pixels wide the side bar is…. hopefully that will e the case in the release version. At this point you can’t detatch the gadgets, but MS showed that ability is changing in the new verison they are going to add back into Vista.
My take on the Side Bar thing is… it’s neat, but I see it finding it’s way to the Active Desktop feature, UNLESS, there are some practical applications bult for this by MS or third parties. It also needs options for the user to decide how much space it can use, and make it more user managable. Oterwise I think it will sit on the desktops of new Vista users for a few days until it becomes more of an intrustion or annoyance in the user experience. But that’s just my view. Tryout the preview and see wat you think.